Review: America by E.R. Frank
Wednesday, September 30th, 2009This year, in honor of the ALA’s Banned Books Week, I will write a review of a challenged book I recently read. For anyone unfamiliar with Banned Books Week, the American Library Association uses the last week of each September to call attention to our right to intellectual freedom and the necessity of vigilence to keep that freedom alive.
Review of America by E.R. Frank
SPOILERS BELOW: YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED.
The first thing I have to admit is that I can completely and totally understand WHY this book was challenged. There is a ton of profanity and child sexual abuse throughout the book. But having said that, it’s also probably one of the most well written and thought provoking books I have ever read in my life. I would not personally recommend this book for children, because it’s very disturbing, but I would definitely recommend it to adults.
The story starts in the middle, told from the point of view of a young, disturbed, institutionalized youth. It’s told in his thought patterns and memories, how he reacts to the people and situations around him, what he thinks is happening. From the middle of this young boy’s life the story progresses in snapshot memories of his childhood until the end of the book when he’s older and a more adjusted member of society. The way the story unfolds is captivating, if not heartbreaking, because you see how tragedy destroys his childhood and innocence, how he “got lost in the system,” how he blamed himself and what he thought about what happened to him. You think you know what messed him up even though he gets “rescued” from his neglectful mother, only to find out that the situation he’s brought into is both better (his Mrs. Harper) and much, MUCH worse. It makes the flashbacks to his early childhood that much more powerful, because you know that love and innocence is destined for a terrible end.
Luckily, the book does have a happier ending. Lucky for me at least because otherwise I probably would have been crying for the next month. This book gripped me like very few have, and I am not at all sorry I read it- especially because I think facing pain and trouble are an important part of life. It made me want to reach out to abused children. The only thing I could fault the book for is that in the end, I was left wondering “What can I do?”… and that was also it’s biggest strength.
Other Articles about Banned Books Week:
American Library Association: Banned Books Week
Mur Lafferty’s “I Should Be Writing” blogpost about “Banned Book Week.
“Stacked (blog): Thoughts on Censorship
Tablet: A new read on Jewish life (complete with a wonderful anticensorship poem)