Book Review: The Cat Who Walked Through Walls by Robert Heinlein
Monday, August 25th, 2008Heinlein has done it again. That statement can be both a positive or a negative, depending on your opinion of his work. My opinion varies, so the statement is meant both ways.
Robert Heinlein is a master, an extremely prolific writer with a real gift for creating intricate plots. There are twists. There are turns. There’s intrigue, adventure, and murder. There’s even a cute little kitten. In the first few pages several major events happen, and the plot never slows down. Through most of the book, I found myself eagerly reading “just one more chapter” to try and figure out just what the hell was going on. It has all the earmarks of a great spy novel set in a futuristic scifi setting. His social commentary is insightful. His monologues alone, humorous diatribes about the business of writing, make the novel worth reading. I admit I highlighted some of those sections. It’s classic Heinlein.
My interest was so engaged, I even overlooked some of Heinlein’s more bizarre sexist writing, particularly group marriage and the supposedly “witty” banter between the main male character and every female (or feminine) character in the book. Typical of Heinlein’s writings in the late 80′s (at least from the novels I’ve read), the hero had every woman, girl, and (Oh how I wish I was kidding) female-personality-type computer throwing themselves at him, wanting to sleep with him, and eventually marry him. I suppose he was just such a prize they couldn’t wait to add him to the harem. Did I mention the group marriage?
So much for the annoying parts. Everything else about the book was great, and I couldn’t wait to reach the ending. I’m going to be somewhat vague, but just in case: SPOILER ALERT. So consider yourself warned.
Three Quarters of the book is spent as a conventional spy novel, albeit in Space, until you suddenly find out the real plot. It’s exciting and awesome and a real page turner. You can’t WAIT to find out how he’s going to explain everything. The main character is finding things out, but he’s indecisive about a crucial decision that’s central to… well, everything. He’s stalling until he has all the information he needs, all the answers to the questions that have been bugging you, the reader, throughout the entire book.
Okay, only ten pages left! Somehow he’s going to wrap this thing up in a spectacular way! Right? Uh… sadly, no. While there is a twist in the last couple pages that I honestly should have seen coming, what with all the sex and group marriages and all, the last pages left me utterly confused. Yes, the event the book has been leading up to all along happened… well, sort of, it doesn’t really resolve anything. I don’t know if Heinlein was trying to leave room for a sequel or what, but the end doesn’t even answer the question of whether they succeeded, whether anyone survived, what actually happened. In short, the ending was not the end. It answered nothing.
I wanted to throw the book at the wall.
So, if you want to read The Cat Who Walks Through Walls for the commentary, the monologues, even the sex… go right ahead. But if you actually expect to have the plot resolved, you’ll be sadly disappointed.
writtenCR 2008-08-19